Canadian Manufacturing

Woman hired by Japan utility for nuclear safety says restarts need to go ahead

by Yuri Kageyama, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS    

Canadian Manufacturing
Operations Sustainability Energy Energy Japan nuclear Safety tsunami

Nuclear power best option for a resource-poor nation like Japan, says Lady Barbara Judge, who chaired the U.K. Atomic Energy Authority from 2004 to 2010.

TOKYO—The Japanese utility still battling leaks of radiated water at the nuclear plant sent into meltdown by the 2011 tsunami thinks it has found the perfect person to oversee its safety campaign—Lady Barbara Judge—a British-American, who has worked as a lawyer, banker and U.S. Securities and Exchange Commissioner.

She says Tokyo Electric Power Co. (Tepco), the utility behind the 2011 Fukushima nuclear catastrophe, has changed enough under a new president to begin restarting its reactors.

Still, she did not mince words about the past practices of the utility linked to the worst nuclear disaster since Chornobyl.

“There was a culture of efficiency, not a culture of safety,” Judge told The Associated Press on Friday, during a trip to Tokyo for meetings at TEPCO. “There was no safety culture. There was an assumption of safety.”


Judge, honorary chairman at the U.K. Atomic Energy Authority, says nuclear power remains the best option for a resource-poor nation like Japan and vows that under her guidance the utility will adhere to world-class safety standards.

Tepco, which hired her for its nuclear reform committee in September, is eager to restart its Kashiwazaki-Kariwa plant, northeast of Tokyo.

New government safety rules are set to kick in next week, signalling a possible go-ahead for some of the 50 idled reactors to get back online.

On Friday, four utilities, Hokkaido, Kansai, Shikoku and Kyushu, told regulators they would apply to restart 10 reactors at five plants, according to the Nuclear Regulation Authority.

Tepco’s president met Friday with the governor and mayors of the Niigata region, where Kashiwazaki-Kariwa is housed, to gain their understanding on the restarts, but was met with doubts and questions about safety measures.

Having undergone a public bailout, Tepco is bleeding money, facing compensation demands from the thousands of people evacuated from around the plant, as well as importing costly oil, coal and gas to keep power going.

All its reactors are either defunct, including the four being decommissioned at Fukushima Dai-ichi, or shut down for safety tests after the disaster. And nuclear plants that can’t restart are a liability, looking terrible on a company’s books.

But Japanese protesters oppose restarting the plants, and public opinion surveys show a majority want an end to atomic power. The ruling party is pro-nuclear, but every other political party is demanding a phase-out.

Decades are likely needed to decommission Fukushima Dai-ichi. A dead rat recently caused a massive blackout, temporarily shutting down the system to keep reactor-cores cool.

Tons of contaminated water continue to leak. Experienced workers are growing harder to find as they reach radiation-exposure limits.

Judge’s answer to such skeptics: Tepco should do more outreach to answer people’s questions and show how nuclear is the superior choice.

She has advised Tepco to “apologize profusely” for the accident and asserts that under her initiative, Tepco is bringing together the toughest standards and safest practices in the world.

Judge served as chairman of the U.K. Atomic Energy Authority from 2004 to 2010.

She insists that the safety-oversight section she is bringing together at TEPCO, instead of being ignored as they were in the past, will be respected, a place for “the best and the brightest.”

She said the standards her team is putting together would be ready “within months.”

After all, the Fukushima accident was set off because backup generators were in the basement when the tsunami struck in March 2011, not a failure of fancy science, she noted.

She pointed to Germany as seeing costly energy imports, worsening carbon emissions and higher electricity prices, while it’s buying nuclear power from France, after opting for a nuclear phase-out.

“It’s a mess,” said Judge. “Life without nuclear is the Emperor’s new clothes, as far as I’m concerned.”


Stories continue below

Print this page

Related Stories