WINNIPEG—Manitoba became the second province to raise the spectre of a court challenge against the federal government’s carbon-pricing plan June 29.
Premier Brian Pallister said he is seeking a legal opinion on whether the federal government has the constitutional authority to force provinces to either impose a price on carbon or set up a cap and trade system.
“In particular, that legal opinion will focus on whether the federal government can limit the exercise of provincial jurisdictions to only two options—cap and trade, and carbon tax—without accommodating other provincial measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions,” Pallister said.
The premier said Manitoba should get credit for billions of dollars spent building up a hydroelectric system that provides 98 per cent of the province’s electricity. Had Manitoba adopted cheaper, fossil-fuel power generation like some other provinces have, he said emissions would be more than double the current 21 megatonnes a year.
“We take some exception to the federal government not recognizing the work that Manitoba and Manitobans have already done on this important file.”
Saskatchewan has already threatened to challenge the carbon pricing plan in court, saying it doesn’t take into account measures taken to reduce emissions such as the province’s carbon capture facility.
“The concerns about recognition (in Manitoba) are very similar to that here in Saskatchewan, as well as the concern about having some degree of latitude to work within your province, not picking one of two different models,” Saskatchewan Environment Minister Scott Moe said Thursday.
Eleven provinces and territories agreed to the carbon price plan in December when they signed the Pan-Canadian Framework on Clean Growth and Climate Change. Saskatchewan and Manitoba have not.
The federal government wants provinces to phase in carbon pricing that would reach $50 a tonne by 2022 or develop a cap and trade system. It has said if provinces don’t act on their own, the federal government will do it for them.
Speaking to reporters in Charlottetown Thursday, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau did not directly answer a question on whether he is confident the federal plan is legally sound. He said Canadians want action taken on climate change, especially those in Manitoba grappling with “extreme weather events and flooding.
“We know that we will continue to work constructively with all premiers on showing the kind of leadership that Canadians expect,” Trudeau said.
Catherine McKenna, the federal environment minister, said Ottawa expects provinces to abide by its plan.
“We will work with Manitoba to find a solution that works for the province while also meeting federal minimum requirements,” McKenna said in a written statement.
“This fall, we will introduce legislation … to price pollution in jurisdictions that do not have their own broad-based pricing systems. This legislation will be consistent with Canada’s Constitution.”
Pallister said Manitoba is still finalizing its own carbon-pricing plan, but the $50-per-tonne level sought by the federal government is too high. Manitobans are already among the highest-taxed residents in the country, he said, and are already paying higher hydro rates to fund new generating capacity.
The Opposition New Democrats said Pallister should sign on to the federal plan to reduce emissions and get federal funding for clean-energy initiatives. NDP environment critic Rob Altemeyer said that might mean a higher price on gasoline but that could be partially offset by rebates for low-income earners.
—with files from Mia Rabson in Ottawa, Michael Tutton in Charlottetown and Jennifer Graham in Regina