Canadian Manufacturing

Trump administration calls Trudeau softwood threat ‘inappropriate’

Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross said the White House will not be pressured by trade threats after the prime minister said Canada is weighing retaliatory action for softwood tariffs

May 8, 2017  by Alexander Panetta, The Canadian Press

U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross said the decision to slap duties on Canadian lumber was based on the facts, not on political calculations

WASHINGTON—The Trump administration says it won’t be pressured by trade threats from the Canadian government, responding May 6 to a warning that the northern neighbour could start targeting American industries in the event of a protracted dispute over softwood lumber.

The administration’s commerce secretary issued a statement calling the threats inappropriate, and insisting they would have no effect on the U.S.’s course of action in the lumber dispute.

Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross made the remarks in spite of numerous outbursts from President Donald Trump about Canadian trade practices over the past several weeks. Trump’s rhetoric has raised tensions between the two neighbours and last month a pair of former American ambassadors to Canada criticized Trump’s comments, calling them counter-productive to resolving trade issues.

In one instance, Trump lashed out against the Canadian dairy industry in a tweet to his millions of followers.


Ross said the decision to slap duties on Canadian lumber was based on the facts presented—not on political calculations.

The U.S. has contended for decades that Canada’s lumber companies are unfairly subsidized through cheap access to public land, and the issue has repeatedly resulted in disputes that include duties, lawsuits, and temporary settlements.

The Canadian government now says it wants a long-term settlement—or else. It’s preparing to target specific industries in the U.S., to put pressure on those Americans backing a hard line on lumber.

Government sources have told The Canadian Press they are weighing two separate actions.

The first was revealed Friday by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. He sent a letter to the premier of B.C., announcing he was seriously considering banning U.S. coal exports from that province and that trade experts were studying it.

Sources say the next step targets the state of Oregon.

The federal government has begun studying all business subsidies in that state, home to Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden. Following that, the Canada Border Services Agency could examine duties on Oregon’s plywood, wine, flooring, wood chips and packaging materials.

Ross brushed aside the threat.

“The decision to impose tariffs on Canadian softwood lumber was based on the facts presented, not on political considerations,” he said in a statement. “If any Canadian or British Columbian official wishes to present additional information (about lumber), we will consider it carefully and impartially…

“Threats of retaliatory action are inappropriate and will not influence any final determinations. We continue to believe that a negotiated settlement is in the best interests of all parties, and we are prepared to work toward that end.”