Japan stunned by Ghosn’s release, critics hope for change
Japan's relatively low crime rate means high-profile cases like former Nissan chairman's are uncommon
Exporting & Importing
Risk & Compliance
TOKYO – Former Nissan chairman Carlos Ghosn’s release from detention nearly four months after his arrest has gripped Japan, giving the public a rare glimpse into how the criminal justice system works.
Ghosn was recuperating Thursday, his lawyer said, after leaving the Tokyo Detention Center the evening before, just in time for his 65th birthday on Saturday. His trial on charges of financial misconduct is sure to draw attention as one of the biggest court cases in the history of corporate Japan.
Japan’s relatively low crime rate means high-profile cases like Ghosn’s are uncommon.
The front pages of all major newspapers carried photos on Thursday of Ghosn after he left the detention centre, his identity obscured by a surgical mask, blue cap and labourer’s clothes.
Broadcasters showed stacks of Japanese currency about the size of a small bed to demonstrate what his bail of 1 billion yen ($8.9 million) would have looked like. The payment was made electronically but the full amount was required, unlike bail systems like in the U.S. where a portion is offered as surety and the full amount is forfeited only if the defendant fails to appear.
While Westerners wondered why the concept of “presumed innocent” doesn’t seem to apply in Japan, many here were shocked his release came so soon.
“An exceptional case of quick release,” said a headline in the newspaper Yomiuri.
Suspects in Japan are usually not released from detention until all documents from both sides are readied for a trial because prosecutors worry that they might tamper with evidence or flee. The court rejected two earlier requests by Ghosn for bail.
Theoretically, suspects in Japan are presumed innocent until proven guilty. But the complexity of a case can determine the length of pretrial detention. And long detentions mean suspects practically serve time before they are found guilty.
Seiho Cho, a defence lawyer, says his clients wonder why they aren’t getting released as quickly as Ghosn was. Ghosn’s legal team offered special conditions, such as a surveillance camera, to win his release.
Bail should be granted without such stringent restrictions, Cho said.
“What we have now is totally wrong,” he said. “We hope this will have a positive effect on future cases.”
Ghosn, who headed the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Motors alliance, has been charged with falsifying financial reports, under-reporting his income and breach of trust in having Nissan shoulder investment losses and make payments to a Saudi businessman. He says he is innocent, that the income allegedly under-reported was never paid or decided, that Nissan never suffered the investment losses and the payments were legitimate business expenses.
The business daily Nikkei said Ghosn’s case highlights inequities human-rights advocates have long criticized as unfair, such as extended detentions and interrogations without a lawyer present. “Japanese-style justice shaken,” the headline said.
There have been several cases in which suspects signed false confessions after harsh questioning during months-long detentions, but were later exonerated by DNA tests or other evidence.
Lawyer Yuichi Kaido welcomed the international scrutiny prompted by Ghosn’s case.
“I realize there is the view that we can’t give special treatment to Mr. Ghosn or that Japan has its own way of doing things,” he said, but “the case of Carlos Ghosn has highlighted how outdated this system is.”
Ghosn has hired a star defence lawyer, Junichiro Hironaka. Nicknamed “the Razor,” he has won rare acquittals in a nation where the conviction rate is 99 per cent.
Hironaka said the lawyer most responsible for securing Ghosn’s release was Takashi Takano, who studied at Southern Methodist University’s law school in Dallas.
“We hope this can serve as a way to end the ‘hostage justice system,”’ Hironaka told reporters Thursday, using the term often used by critics to refer to long detentions typical in Japan.
“The world is watching.”
AP journalist Kaori Hitomi in Tokyo contributed to this report.