Canadian Manufacturing

TransCanada to face just one Quebec injunction after court ruling

Quebec launched the injunction to force TransCanada to provide a more detailed account of its Energy East proposal

March 31, 2016  by The Canadian Press

MONTREAL—TransCanada will have to fight just one injunction request related to its Energy East pipeline project after a March 30 court ruling.

An environmental law group, acting on behalf of several organizations, was seeking an injunction to force TransCanada to be subject to Quebec’s Environment Quality Act.

But Quebec Superior Court Justice Martin Castonguay ruled the legal proceedings can be folded into a similar court action that has been launched by the Quebec government.

Quebec wants TransCanada to provide a more detailed account of its Energy East proposal, which would result in a more complete environmental review process than the one currently taking place.


TransCanada lawyer Robert Torralbo argued it was up to Quebec’s attorney general to ask the courts to force a company to respect a law and that citizens cannot make such a demand unless the government refuses to do so.

Although Castonguay noted the environmental law group’s application for an injunction came before the Quebec government’s, he ruled that it was reasonable to combine the requests to avoid multiple, similar cases.

Quebec’s environmental review agency is scheduled to begin a second round of public hearings into the Energy East proposal on April 25.

The first hearings wrapped up in March with citizens from across the province grilling TransCanada executives on the risks and costs associated with the pipeline.

Energy East would bring 1.1 million barrels of oil a day from Alberta and Saskatchewan through Quebec and onto News Brunswick for overseas shipping.

Environmentalists argue the pipeline will increase Canada’s greenhouse gas emissions and prevent the country from meeting its climate change commitments.

Proponents of the pipeline say Alberta’s oilsands need to be developed for the country to grow its GDP and have the money available to transition to a lower-carbon economy.