Canadian Manufacturing

McKenna ‘disappointed’ Ontario doesn’t have plan to fight climate change

The Canadian Press

Cleantech Canada
Environment Regulation Energy Public Sector

The federal environment minister says she pressed her Ontario counterpart for details on the province's plan to fight climate change but he declined to provide them

“Climate change doesn’t stop with a change in government,” said McKenna. PHOTO: Canada 2020/Twitter

TORONTO—The federal environment minister expressed disappointment Wednesday that Ontario did not seem to have a plan to fight climate change, a conclusion she said she reached after her first meeting with her provincial counterpart.

Catherine McKenna’s discussion with Rod Phillips came as the provincial Progressive Conservatives, who took office last month, have been taking steps to scrap Ontario’s cap-and-trade system.

McKenna said she pressed Phillips for details on the province’s plan to fight climate change but he declined to provide them.

“I’m disappointed to see the new government in Ontario has no plan to help families, schools and businesses reduce emissions, save money and create good jobs,” McKenna said in a statement after the meeting. “Climate change doesn’t stop with a change in government.”


Phillips said he offered to discuss the Tory government’s opposition to carbon pricing but said the federal minister would not address the subject.

“I was hoping that she would be open to discussion, to listening to our plans around climate change, and of course our intention to get rid of the carbon tax,” he said.

“I was disappointed. The minister was not open to that discussion, and unfortunately made it clear that only the Trudeau carbon tax solution is the solution that government is going to be interested in.”

Related: Moe, Ford join together to oppose federal carbon pricing at N.B. meeting

The federal government has pledged to “backstop” any province that does not have a carbon price by imposing one of its own, something the Ford government has vowed to challenge in court.

Phillips said, however, that a protracted court battle doesn’t have to be the only outcome.

“We don’t need to go to court about this,” he said. “We need to let Ontario bring forward their plan. We need to not be dogmatic about it.”

When pressed for details on the Tory plan to tackle climate change, Phillips said details would be provided when the plan was ready.

Cap-and-trade was introduced by Ontario’s former Liberal government to put limits on the amount of acceptable emissions and create incentives for industry to invest in reducing their carbon footprint.

A week after winning the June 7 election, Premier Doug Ford said the Tories would provide clear rules for an “orderly wind down” of cap-and-trade, and would give notice of Ontario’s withdrawal from the carbon pricing market it shares with Quebec and California.

Ford’s team has estimated challenging the federal carbon tax in court would cost taxpayers $30 million over four years.


Stories continue below